In the Crosshairs: Arbitrary Policing and the Challenges of Defining Extremism

 

Arbitrary Policing: Conflicting Arrests and Concerns Over New Extremism Definition

Excessive Force and Inconsistent Policing

On March 27th, an individual was arrested during a demonstration for holding a sign that read 'Hamas is a terrorist organization.' Despite peacefully holding the sign, the man was dragged away and initially arrested for assault, although no one complained of being assaulted. This incident highlights the police's inconsistent responses to similar situations, as counter-protesters who harassed and tore the sign from him were not arrested.

Lack of Clarity and Communication

The Met Police's social media team inaccurately reported that the individual was arrested for 'breach of peace' and 'assault,' even though no one claimed to have been assaulted. This raises concerns about the reliability of police statements and their lack of proper investigation.

Selective Enforcement

While certain protesters are arrested for holding up signs criticizing Hamas, others are allowed to chant slogans calling for the eradication of Israel. This inconsistency in policing suggests a bias against those who challenge the narrative of the protesters.

Concerns over Extremism Definition

The government's upcoming definition of extremism raises concerns that it may be expanded to target legitimate speech and dissent. Critics argue that it could potentially label actions such as criticizing Islamist extremism as extremist rhetoric, potentially stifling free expression.

Arbitrary Justice and Lack of Accountability

The subjective nature of policing and the inconsistency of laws across different areas create a 'postcode lottery' of justice. Individuals may face different treatment based on the officers they encounter, leading to arbitrary enforcement and a lack of accountability.

Conclusion

The arrest of the individual holding a sign highlights the arbitrary and inconsistent nature of policing at demonstrations. The proposed extremism definition raises concerns over potential suppression of legitimate debate. Citizens should hold the police accountable and demand clarity and fairness in law enforcement to ensure justice is applied equally.